Home » Blood Health » Evaluating the best in new health technologies
Blood Health 2019

Evaluating the best in new health technologies

iStock / Getty Images Pluys / Dr_Microbe

Dr Máirín Ryan

Deputy CEO and Director of Health Technology Assessment at the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA)

Healthcare is evolving rapidly. To maximise public health, the health service and government need independent information on the most effective technologies to invest in.

In HIQA, we independently assess whether new drugs, vaccines, equipment or tests are safe and effective.[1] This work is called health technology assessment (or HTA). During an HTA we also look at organisational, ethical, social or medico-legal issues around introducing a new technology, as well as assessing whether it would be cost-effective if introduced into the Irish healthcare system.

This process ensures that decision-makers, such as the government and health services, can make informed decisions based on unbiased and transparent evidence on how best the finite health budget is spent.

Our work has included advice on the introduction of new vaccination, cancer screening and smoking cessation programmes. Earlier this year we assessed the introduction of a PrEP programme to prevent HIV in Ireland and provided advice to the Minister for Health.[2] Our evaluation of PrEP found that providing the medication to those most at risk of acquiring blood-borne HIV would be safe, effective and cost-saving to the taxpayer.

Recently, we commenced a new assessment on offering hepatitis C testing to all people in Ireland born between 1965 and 1985.

Hepatitis C is most often found in people in Ireland born between 1965 and 1985

Hepatitis C is a blood-borne virus, which predominantly affects the liver. In Ireland, the birth-cohort of people born between 1965 and 1985 makes up the majority of all hepatitis C cases.[3]

Our next HTA will establish the clinical benefit, cost-effectiveness and budget impact of offering hepatitis C testing to this birth-cohort. Those diagnosed with hepatitis C will be offered effective treatment. Assessment of this programme was recommended by the National Clinical Guideline on Hepatitis C Screening.

Assessing a potential hepatitis C testing programme

In evaluating a health technology, we aim to address a number of questions, including:

  • Can the technology work?
  • Does it offer benefits in practice?
  • Does it represent a good use of resources?
  • Is it affordable?
  • Are there other important considerations, such as organisational, ethical or societal implications?

To help us, we established an expert advisory group with representation from clinicians with specialist expertise in hepatitis C screening and treatment, the National Screening Service, the National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics and patient advocates, the Irish Haemophilia Society and SAGE Advocacy.

Following a systematic review of the evidence on clinical effectiveness and safety and development of an economic model to assess cost-effectiveness and budget impact, we will hold a public consultation. This is an opportunity for people affected, clinicians and the wider public to tell us their views about the assessment of birth-cohort testing for hepatitis C before we finalise the report.

Once approved by the Board of HIQA, our independent, evidence-based advice will be submitted to the Minister for Health to allow him to make an informed decision on whether to implement a hepatitis C birth-cohort testing programme. The overall aim is to ensure best use of resources to maximise health benefits for the population.

1 https://www.hiqa.ie/reports-and-publications/health-technology-assessments/guide-health-technology-assessment-hiqa|
2 https://www.hiqa.ie/reports-and-publications/health-technology-assessment/hta-prep-programme
3 Garvey P, O’Grady B, Franzoni G, Bolger M, Irwin Crosby K, Connell J, et al. Hepatitis C virus seroprevalence and prevalence of chronic infection in the adult population in Ireland: a study of residual sera, April 2014 to February 2016.

Next article